SlideShare a Scribd company logo
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -1- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
Multi-Terminal Power Hardware-in-the-Loop
Test-Bench for Power System Stability
Analyses Focused on Distributed Generation
RT15
Berkeley, CA | 13 - 14 June, 2015
Authors: Ron Brandl, Fraunhofer IWES
Dominik Geibel, Fraunhofer IWES
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -2- Ron Brandl, Project: DEAstabil
Multi-Terminal PHIL Test Bench for Power
System Stability Analyses
Content
1. Introduction
2. Power System Stability (PSS)
3. Simulation Environment
4. Hardware Environment
5. Power Hardware-in-the-Loop (PHIL) Simulation
6. Conclusion
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -3- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
1. Introduction
Motivation
 Large increase in inverter-coupled generating units
 In Germany over 50% of power generation is from PV and wind at certain times
Change of future network
 Loss of spinning reserves
 Decentralization of power production
 Future mix of power plant park will
be inverter-dominated
 Power system stability (PSS)
has to be assured
Transformation to inverter-dominated networks
0
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
70000
80000
0:00
1:00
2:00
3:00
4:00
5:00
6:00
7:00
8:00
9:00
10:00
11:00
12:00
13:00
14:00
15:00
16:00
17:00
18:00
19:00
20:00
21:00
22:00
23:00
ProductioninMW
Conventional Production > 100MW Wind Solar
18th April 2013 in Germany
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -4- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
2. Power System Stability
Conventional PSS
 Focused on rotating generators
 Rotor angle stability
 Frequency stability
 Voltage stability
 Reconsideration of conventional
stability assessment Source: Definition and Classification of Power System Stability, IEEE/CIGRE Joint
Task Force, P. Kundur et. al.
Definition of Stability
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -5- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
2. Power System Stability
Factors for network imbalance
 Failure/blackout of
 central power plants
 large loads
 transmission line
 HVDC terminals
 Switching operations on transmission network
 Weather influence
 Change of active coupling points of the interconnection to boundary networks
Scenarios for different PSS disturbances
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -6- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
2. Power System Stability
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -7- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
3. Simulation Environment
Intention of new simulation
platform
 Holistic simulation of transmission
and distribution network for stability
studies
 Include dynamics of decentralized
generators in the distribution
network
 Ability to conduct real-time
simulations, esp. PHIL simulations
 Evaluation of the future needs of
the power system, with increasing
inverter-based generation, on a
scientific basis
Motivation
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -8- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
3. Simulation Environment
German interconnection network
 Holistic stability analyses required
 >> 100.000 nodes and machines from
high voltage down to low voltage level
Handling
 Aggregated models of distribution
networks with dynamic behaviors
 Development of models ≤ 110 kV
which are scalable and containing the
influence of distribution generators
 Verification of network models based
on available data of real network
disturbance
Dynamic Model of Distribution Networks
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -9- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
3. Simulation Environment
Benefits/Summary
Advantage
 Use of self-made simulation models
 Access to calculation equations and simulation routine
Challenges
 Development of a holistic interconnection network simulation
 Real-time capability and compatibility with real-time products
 Parallel simulation on different cores is necessary, due to high numbers of nodes
General Benefits
 Flexibility  total access for developer possible
 Scalability  Level of detail user defined
 Expansion to new research fields
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -10- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
4. Hardware Environment
Laboratory Test bench
Power Hardware-in-the-Loop test bench
 Development, construction and operation
of PHIL test Bench
 Demonstration of the contribution of
distributed generators (DER) to power
system stability in a laboratory environment
 Verification of the influence of power-
stabilizing control method from inverter-
based generators by coupling real-time
simulations with larger transmission and
distribution networks
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -11- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
4. Hardware Environment
Laboratory (under preparation)
 Systec Laboratory, Fraunhofer IWES
 Power Hardware-in-the-Loop test bench
 Ametek, Power amplifier, 3x 3phase 90 kVA (single/parallel operation)
 Scienlab, DC-source (battery emulator), 290 kW
 TriPhase, DC-DC-AC inverter, 2x 15 kVA
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -12- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
5. Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Simulation
Benefits/Summary
Intention of Power Hardware-in-the-Loop simulation
 Integration of „black box“ devices for stability support (e.g. converters)
 Level of detail increased due to use of the real hardware in comparison to software
models
 All effects of the hardware can be monitored
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -13- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
5. Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Simulation
Network Simulation Scheme
German interconnection
network
 Transmission level
 2.000 nodes
 1.000 machine
 Distribution level
 Aggregated models
 4.500 active nodes
 4.000 machines
 Connection point HUT
 Current feedback circuit
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -14- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
5. Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Simulation
Simulation platform
Controlled execution
 Higher-ranked phasor simulation
 Transmission network simulation
 Adaption/Integration of self-made
models
 Classified aggregated distribution
network
 Distributed generator
 Wind park
 Photovoltaic system
 CHPs
 HVDC link
 …
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -15- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
6. Conclusion
Summary
Summary
 Reconsideration of power system stability
 Focusing of inverter-dominated generators in future
 Creating of holistic network simulation for stability analyses
 Scenarios of conventional PSS
 Research of new/upcoming PSS
 Power Hardware-in-the-Loop
 Laboratory Test – “Black Box” or self-programmed inverter testing
Outlook
 Network simulation for stability studies
 Development of new control strategies for DER
 Advanced test platform for DER
© Fraunhofer IWES
Slide -16- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil
Thanks for your attention
Ron Brandl
Fraunhofer Intitute of Wind Energy and Energy System Technologies
Koenigstor 59
34119 Kassel/Germany
Ron.Brandl@iwes.fraunhofer.de
Acknowledgement
We acknowledge the support of our work by the
German Ministry for the Environment, Nature and
Nuclear Safety and the Projekträger Jülich within
the project “DEA-Stabil: Beitrag der Windenergie
und Photovoltaik im Verteilungsnetz zur Stabilität
des deutschen Verbundnetzes” (FKZ 0325585).
Ad

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

RT15 Berkeley | ePHASORsim: Real-time transient stability simulation tool - O...
RT15 Berkeley | ePHASORsim: Real-time transient stability simulation tool - O...RT15 Berkeley | ePHASORsim: Real-time transient stability simulation tool - O...
RT15 Berkeley | ePHASORsim: Real-time transient stability simulation tool - O...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | Power HIL Simulator (SimP) A prototype to develop a high band...
RT15 Berkeley | Power HIL Simulator (SimP) A prototype to develop a high band...RT15 Berkeley | Power HIL Simulator (SimP) A prototype to develop a high band...
RT15 Berkeley | Power HIL Simulator (SimP) A prototype to develop a high band...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | Optimized Power Flow Control in Microgrids - Sandia Laboratory
RT15 Berkeley | Optimized Power Flow Control in Microgrids - Sandia LaboratoryRT15 Berkeley | Optimized Power Flow Control in Microgrids - Sandia Laboratory
RT15 Berkeley | Optimized Power Flow Control in Microgrids - Sandia Laboratory
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration PlatformMicrogrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Darcy La Ronde
 
Rapid Control Prototyping Solutions
Rapid Control Prototyping SolutionsRapid Control Prototyping Solutions
Rapid Control Prototyping Solutions
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
OPAL-RT | Setup and Performance of a Combined Hardware-in-loop and Software-i...
OPAL-RT | Setup and Performance of a Combined Hardware-in-loop and Software-i...OPAL-RT | Setup and Performance of a Combined Hardware-in-loop and Software-i...
OPAL-RT | Setup and Performance of a Combined Hardware-in-loop and Software-i...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Residential Battery Storage Systems. Des...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Residential Battery Storage Systems. Des...2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Residential Battery Storage Systems. Des...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Residential Battery Storage Systems. Des...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Volt/Var Optimization Scheme f...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Volt/Var Optimization Scheme f...2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Volt/Var Optimization Scheme f...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Volt/Var Optimization Scheme f...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | Real-time simulation as a prime tool for Cybersecurity - OPAL-RT
RT15 Berkeley | Real-time simulation as a prime tool for Cybersecurity - OPAL-RTRT15 Berkeley | Real-time simulation as a prime tool for Cybersecurity - OPAL-RT
RT15 Berkeley | Real-time simulation as a prime tool for Cybersecurity - OPAL-RT
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Using OPAL-RT Real-Time Simulation and H...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Using OPAL-RT Real-Time Simulation and H...2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Using OPAL-RT Real-Time Simulation and H...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Using OPAL-RT Real-Time Simulation and H...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar Introduction
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar Introduction2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar Introduction
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar Introduction
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | Introduction to FPGA Power Electronic & Electric Machine real...
RT15 Berkeley | Introduction to FPGA Power Electronic & Electric Machine real...RT15 Berkeley | Introduction to FPGA Power Electronic & Electric Machine real...
RT15 Berkeley | Introduction to FPGA Power Electronic & Electric Machine real...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | NI / OPAL-RT Power Electronics HIL Teaching Laboratory - Nati...
RT15 Berkeley | NI / OPAL-RT Power Electronics HIL Teaching Laboratory - Nati...RT15 Berkeley | NI / OPAL-RT Power Electronics HIL Teaching Laboratory - Nati...
RT15 Berkeley | NI / OPAL-RT Power Electronics HIL Teaching Laboratory - Nati...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
OPAL-RT and RTDS Technologies Co-Simulation
OPAL-RT and RTDS Technologies Co-SimulationOPAL-RT and RTDS Technologies Co-Simulation
OPAL-RT and RTDS Technologies Co-Simulation
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Virtualizing Industrial Control Systems ...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Virtualizing Industrial Control Systems ...2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Virtualizing Industrial Control Systems ...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Virtualizing Industrial Control Systems ...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Webinar | HIL-based Wide-area Monitoring, Protection and Control R&D and Testing
Webinar | HIL-based Wide-area Monitoring, Protection and Control R&D and TestingWebinar | HIL-based Wide-area Monitoring, Protection and Control R&D and Testing
Webinar | HIL-based Wide-area Monitoring, Protection and Control R&D and Testing
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Microgrid Demos
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Microgrid Demos2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Microgrid Demos
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Microgrid Demos
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
OPAL-RT Power Hardware-In-the-Loop presentation
OPAL-RT Power Hardware-In-the-Loop presentationOPAL-RT Power Hardware-In-the-Loop presentation
OPAL-RT Power Hardware-In-the-Loop presentation
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | End-to-End Simulation Solution for Smart Grids Applications -...
RT15 Berkeley | End-to-End Simulation Solution for Smart Grids Applications -...RT15 Berkeley | End-to-End Simulation Solution for Smart Grids Applications -...
RT15 Berkeley | End-to-End Simulation Solution for Smart Grids Applications -...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
OPAL-RT Model-In-the-Loop real-time simulation
OPAL-RT Model-In-the-Loop real-time simulation OPAL-RT Model-In-the-Loop real-time simulation
OPAL-RT Model-In-the-Loop real-time simulation
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | ePHASORsim: Real-time transient stability simulation tool - O...
RT15 Berkeley | ePHASORsim: Real-time transient stability simulation tool - O...RT15 Berkeley | ePHASORsim: Real-time transient stability simulation tool - O...
RT15 Berkeley | ePHASORsim: Real-time transient stability simulation tool - O...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | Power HIL Simulator (SimP) A prototype to develop a high band...
RT15 Berkeley | Power HIL Simulator (SimP) A prototype to develop a high band...RT15 Berkeley | Power HIL Simulator (SimP) A prototype to develop a high band...
RT15 Berkeley | Power HIL Simulator (SimP) A prototype to develop a high band...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | Optimized Power Flow Control in Microgrids - Sandia Laboratory
RT15 Berkeley | Optimized Power Flow Control in Microgrids - Sandia LaboratoryRT15 Berkeley | Optimized Power Flow Control in Microgrids - Sandia Laboratory
RT15 Berkeley | Optimized Power Flow Control in Microgrids - Sandia Laboratory
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration PlatformMicrogrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Darcy La Ronde
 
Rapid Control Prototyping Solutions
Rapid Control Prototyping SolutionsRapid Control Prototyping Solutions
Rapid Control Prototyping Solutions
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
OPAL-RT | Setup and Performance of a Combined Hardware-in-loop and Software-i...
OPAL-RT | Setup and Performance of a Combined Hardware-in-loop and Software-i...OPAL-RT | Setup and Performance of a Combined Hardware-in-loop and Software-i...
OPAL-RT | Setup and Performance of a Combined Hardware-in-loop and Software-i...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Residential Battery Storage Systems. Des...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Residential Battery Storage Systems. Des...2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Residential Battery Storage Systems. Des...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Residential Battery Storage Systems. Des...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Volt/Var Optimization Scheme f...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Volt/Var Optimization Scheme f...2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Volt/Var Optimization Scheme f...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Volt/Var Optimization Scheme f...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | Real-time simulation as a prime tool for Cybersecurity - OPAL-RT
RT15 Berkeley | Real-time simulation as a prime tool for Cybersecurity - OPAL-RTRT15 Berkeley | Real-time simulation as a prime tool for Cybersecurity - OPAL-RT
RT15 Berkeley | Real-time simulation as a prime tool for Cybersecurity - OPAL-RT
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Using OPAL-RT Real-Time Simulation and H...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Using OPAL-RT Real-Time Simulation and H...2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Using OPAL-RT Real-Time Simulation and H...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Using OPAL-RT Real-Time Simulation and H...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar Introduction
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar Introduction2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar Introduction
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar Introduction
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | Introduction to FPGA Power Electronic & Electric Machine real...
RT15 Berkeley | Introduction to FPGA Power Electronic & Electric Machine real...RT15 Berkeley | Introduction to FPGA Power Electronic & Electric Machine real...
RT15 Berkeley | Introduction to FPGA Power Electronic & Electric Machine real...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | NI / OPAL-RT Power Electronics HIL Teaching Laboratory - Nati...
RT15 Berkeley | NI / OPAL-RT Power Electronics HIL Teaching Laboratory - Nati...RT15 Berkeley | NI / OPAL-RT Power Electronics HIL Teaching Laboratory - Nati...
RT15 Berkeley | NI / OPAL-RT Power Electronics HIL Teaching Laboratory - Nati...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
OPAL-RT and RTDS Technologies Co-Simulation
OPAL-RT and RTDS Technologies Co-SimulationOPAL-RT and RTDS Technologies Co-Simulation
OPAL-RT and RTDS Technologies Co-Simulation
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Virtualizing Industrial Control Systems ...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Virtualizing Industrial Control Systems ...2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Virtualizing Industrial Control Systems ...
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Virtualizing Industrial Control Systems ...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Webinar | HIL-based Wide-area Monitoring, Protection and Control R&D and Testing
Webinar | HIL-based Wide-area Monitoring, Protection and Control R&D and TestingWebinar | HIL-based Wide-area Monitoring, Protection and Control R&D and Testing
Webinar | HIL-based Wide-area Monitoring, Protection and Control R&D and Testing
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Microgrid Demos
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Microgrid Demos2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Microgrid Demos
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Real-Time Microgrid Demos
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
OPAL-RT Power Hardware-In-the-Loop presentation
OPAL-RT Power Hardware-In-the-Loop presentationOPAL-RT Power Hardware-In-the-Loop presentation
OPAL-RT Power Hardware-In-the-Loop presentation
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | End-to-End Simulation Solution for Smart Grids Applications -...
RT15 Berkeley | End-to-End Simulation Solution for Smart Grids Applications -...RT15 Berkeley | End-to-End Simulation Solution for Smart Grids Applications -...
RT15 Berkeley | End-to-End Simulation Solution for Smart Grids Applications -...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
OPAL-RT Model-In-the-Loop real-time simulation
OPAL-RT Model-In-the-Loop real-time simulation OPAL-RT Model-In-the-Loop real-time simulation
OPAL-RT Model-In-the-Loop real-time simulation
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 

Similar to RT15 Berkeley | Multi-Terminal Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Test-Bench for Power System Stability Analyses Focused on Distributed Generation - Fraunhofer (20)

OPAL-RT RT13: Real time simulation of distribution grids
OPAL-RT RT13: Real time simulation of distribution gridsOPAL-RT RT13: Real time simulation of distribution grids
OPAL-RT RT13: Real time simulation of distribution grids
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Completely Wireless Real-Time Sensors for Smart Factory Applications
Completely Wireless Real-Time Sensors for Smart Factory ApplicationsCompletely Wireless Real-Time Sensors for Smart Factory Applications
Completely Wireless Real-Time Sensors for Smart Factory Applications
M2M Alliance e.V.
 
Using Blockchain-Technologies for Factory Automation
Using Blockchain-Technologies for Factory Automation Using Blockchain-Technologies for Factory Automation
Using Blockchain-Technologies for Factory Automation
M2M Alliance e.V.
 
25 7th energy-rating-and-module-performance-modeling-workshop-eisenlohr_final
25 7th energy-rating-and-module-performance-modeling-workshop-eisenlohr_final25 7th energy-rating-and-module-performance-modeling-workshop-eisenlohr_final
25 7th energy-rating-and-module-performance-modeling-workshop-eisenlohr_final
Sandia National Laboratories: Energy & Climate: Renewables
 
Broadband tech 2005
Broadband tech 2005Broadband tech 2005
Broadband tech 2005
eaiti
 
Cired 2015 poster1037: DISTRIBUTED AND COORDINATED DEMAND RESPONSE FOR THE S...
Cired 2015 poster1037:  DISTRIBUTED AND COORDINATED DEMAND RESPONSE FOR THE S...Cired 2015 poster1037:  DISTRIBUTED AND COORDINATED DEMAND RESPONSE FOR THE S...
Cired 2015 poster1037: DISTRIBUTED AND COORDINATED DEMAND RESPONSE FOR THE S...
Gaspard Lebel
 
2014 PV Distribution System Modeling Workshop: Communications and control – A...
2014 PV Distribution System Modeling Workshop: Communications and control – A...2014 PV Distribution System Modeling Workshop: Communications and control – A...
2014 PV Distribution System Modeling Workshop: Communications and control – A...
Sandia National Laboratories: Energy & Climate: Renewables
 
OPAL-RT & Hydro-Quebec - HYPERSIM
OPAL-RT & Hydro-Quebec - HYPERSIMOPAL-RT & Hydro-Quebec - HYPERSIM
OPAL-RT & Hydro-Quebec - HYPERSIM
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
OPAL-RT RT14 Conference: Real-time simulator for power system studies
OPAL-RT RT14 Conference: Real-time simulator for power system studiesOPAL-RT RT14 Conference: Real-time simulator for power system studies
OPAL-RT RT14 Conference: Real-time simulator for power system studies
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Wireless smart sensors for condition monitoring
Wireless smart sensors for condition monitoringWireless smart sensors for condition monitoring
Wireless smart sensors for condition monitoring
Dirk Mayer
 
The RaPId Toolbox for Parameter Identification and Model Validation: How Mode...
The RaPId Toolbox for Parameter Identification and Model Validation: How Mode...The RaPId Toolbox for Parameter Identification and Model Validation: How Mode...
The RaPId Toolbox for Parameter Identification and Model Validation: How Mode...
Luigi Vanfretti
 
Detailed modeling of complex BIPV systems
Detailed modeling of complex BIPV systemsDetailed modeling of complex BIPV systems
Detailed modeling of complex BIPV systems
Sandia National Laboratories: Energy & Climate: Renewables
 
Methodical Design of Vibration Energy Harvesting Systems
Methodical Design of Vibration Energy Harvesting SystemsMethodical Design of Vibration Energy Harvesting Systems
Methodical Design of Vibration Energy Harvesting Systems
Dirk Mayer
 
Dynamic wind turbine models in power system simulation tool DIgSILENT.pdf
Dynamic wind turbine models in power system simulation tool DIgSILENT.pdfDynamic wind turbine models in power system simulation tool DIgSILENT.pdf
Dynamic wind turbine models in power system simulation tool DIgSILENT.pdf
StefaniadeOliveiraSi
 
7 a.metz - halm ok
7   a.metz - halm ok7   a.metz - halm ok
7 a.metz - halm ok
Sandia National Laboratories: Energy & Climate: Renewables
 
03 christian reise - fraunhofer
03   christian reise - fraunhofer03   christian reise - fraunhofer
03 christian reise - fraunhofer
Paul van der Linden
 
OPAL-RT Webinar - HYPERSIM
OPAL-RT Webinar - HYPERSIMOPAL-RT Webinar - HYPERSIM
OPAL-RT Webinar - HYPERSIM
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
B5 g2 enhanced+protection+functionality+with+iec+61850+and+goose
B5 g2 enhanced+protection+functionality+with+iec+61850+and+gooseB5 g2 enhanced+protection+functionality+with+iec+61850+and+goose
B5 g2 enhanced+protection+functionality+with+iec+61850+and+goose
Omeal Ahmed
 
Industry outlook_ ABB.pdf
Industry outlook_ ABB.pdfIndustry outlook_ ABB.pdf
Industry outlook_ ABB.pdf
ssuser8073a0
 
VTT Wireless access - More radio capacity with less energy
VTT Wireless access - More radio capacity with less energyVTT Wireless access - More radio capacity with less energy
VTT Wireless access - More radio capacity with less energy
VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland Ltd
 
OPAL-RT RT13: Real time simulation of distribution grids
OPAL-RT RT13: Real time simulation of distribution gridsOPAL-RT RT13: Real time simulation of distribution grids
OPAL-RT RT13: Real time simulation of distribution grids
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Completely Wireless Real-Time Sensors for Smart Factory Applications
Completely Wireless Real-Time Sensors for Smart Factory ApplicationsCompletely Wireless Real-Time Sensors for Smart Factory Applications
Completely Wireless Real-Time Sensors for Smart Factory Applications
M2M Alliance e.V.
 
Using Blockchain-Technologies for Factory Automation
Using Blockchain-Technologies for Factory Automation Using Blockchain-Technologies for Factory Automation
Using Blockchain-Technologies for Factory Automation
M2M Alliance e.V.
 
Broadband tech 2005
Broadband tech 2005Broadband tech 2005
Broadband tech 2005
eaiti
 
Cired 2015 poster1037: DISTRIBUTED AND COORDINATED DEMAND RESPONSE FOR THE S...
Cired 2015 poster1037:  DISTRIBUTED AND COORDINATED DEMAND RESPONSE FOR THE S...Cired 2015 poster1037:  DISTRIBUTED AND COORDINATED DEMAND RESPONSE FOR THE S...
Cired 2015 poster1037: DISTRIBUTED AND COORDINATED DEMAND RESPONSE FOR THE S...
Gaspard Lebel
 
OPAL-RT RT14 Conference: Real-time simulator for power system studies
OPAL-RT RT14 Conference: Real-time simulator for power system studiesOPAL-RT RT14 Conference: Real-time simulator for power system studies
OPAL-RT RT14 Conference: Real-time simulator for power system studies
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Wireless smart sensors for condition monitoring
Wireless smart sensors for condition monitoringWireless smart sensors for condition monitoring
Wireless smart sensors for condition monitoring
Dirk Mayer
 
The RaPId Toolbox for Parameter Identification and Model Validation: How Mode...
The RaPId Toolbox for Parameter Identification and Model Validation: How Mode...The RaPId Toolbox for Parameter Identification and Model Validation: How Mode...
The RaPId Toolbox for Parameter Identification and Model Validation: How Mode...
Luigi Vanfretti
 
Methodical Design of Vibration Energy Harvesting Systems
Methodical Design of Vibration Energy Harvesting SystemsMethodical Design of Vibration Energy Harvesting Systems
Methodical Design of Vibration Energy Harvesting Systems
Dirk Mayer
 
Dynamic wind turbine models in power system simulation tool DIgSILENT.pdf
Dynamic wind turbine models in power system simulation tool DIgSILENT.pdfDynamic wind turbine models in power system simulation tool DIgSILENT.pdf
Dynamic wind turbine models in power system simulation tool DIgSILENT.pdf
StefaniadeOliveiraSi
 
B5 g2 enhanced+protection+functionality+with+iec+61850+and+goose
B5 g2 enhanced+protection+functionality+with+iec+61850+and+gooseB5 g2 enhanced+protection+functionality+with+iec+61850+and+goose
B5 g2 enhanced+protection+functionality+with+iec+61850+and+goose
Omeal Ahmed
 
Industry outlook_ ABB.pdf
Industry outlook_ ABB.pdfIndustry outlook_ ABB.pdf
Industry outlook_ ABB.pdf
ssuser8073a0
 
Ad

More from OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES (7)

Detailed large-scale real-time HYPERSIM EMT simulation for transient stabilit...
Detailed large-scale real-time HYPERSIM EMT simulation for transient stabilit...Detailed large-scale real-time HYPERSIM EMT simulation for transient stabilit...
Detailed large-scale real-time HYPERSIM EMT simulation for transient stabilit...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Conclusion
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Conclusion 2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Conclusion
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Conclusion
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Comparison of Non-real-time and Real-time Simulators with Relays-in-the-Loop ...
Comparison of Non-real-time and Real-time Simulators with Relays-in-the-Loop ...Comparison of Non-real-time and Real-time Simulators with Relays-in-the-Loop ...
Comparison of Non-real-time and Real-time Simulators with Relays-in-the-Loop ...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Webinar | HIL Testing of Electric Transportation
Webinar | HIL Testing of Electric TransportationWebinar | HIL Testing of Electric Transportation
Webinar | HIL Testing of Electric Transportation
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Lab-Scale MMC Test Bench
Lab-Scale MMC Test BenchLab-Scale MMC Test Bench
Lab-Scale MMC Test Bench
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | Requirements on Power Amplifiers and HIL Real-Time Processors...
RT15 Berkeley | Requirements on Power Amplifiers and HIL Real-Time Processors...RT15 Berkeley | Requirements on Power Amplifiers and HIL Real-Time Processors...
RT15 Berkeley | Requirements on Power Amplifiers and HIL Real-Time Processors...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Detailed large-scale real-time HYPERSIM EMT simulation for transient stabilit...
Detailed large-scale real-time HYPERSIM EMT simulation for transient stabilit...Detailed large-scale real-time HYPERSIM EMT simulation for transient stabilit...
Detailed large-scale real-time HYPERSIM EMT simulation for transient stabilit...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Conclusion
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Conclusion 2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Conclusion
2017 Atlanta Regional User Seminar - Conclusion
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Comparison of Non-real-time and Real-time Simulators with Relays-in-the-Loop ...
Comparison of Non-real-time and Real-time Simulators with Relays-in-the-Loop ...Comparison of Non-real-time and Real-time Simulators with Relays-in-the-Loop ...
Comparison of Non-real-time and Real-time Simulators with Relays-in-the-Loop ...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Webinar | HIL Testing of Electric Transportation
Webinar | HIL Testing of Electric TransportationWebinar | HIL Testing of Electric Transportation
Webinar | HIL Testing of Electric Transportation
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
Microgrid Controller HIL Demonstration Platform
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
RT15 Berkeley | Requirements on Power Amplifiers and HIL Real-Time Processors...
RT15 Berkeley | Requirements on Power Amplifiers and HIL Real-Time Processors...RT15 Berkeley | Requirements on Power Amplifiers and HIL Real-Time Processors...
RT15 Berkeley | Requirements on Power Amplifiers and HIL Real-Time Processors...
OPAL-RT TECHNOLOGIES
 
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

22PCOAM16 ML Unit 3 Full notes PDF & QB.pdf
22PCOAM16 ML Unit 3 Full notes PDF & QB.pdf22PCOAM16 ML Unit 3 Full notes PDF & QB.pdf
22PCOAM16 ML Unit 3 Full notes PDF & QB.pdf
Guru Nanak Technical Institutions
 
hypermedia_system_revisit_roy_fielding .
hypermedia_system_revisit_roy_fielding .hypermedia_system_revisit_roy_fielding .
hypermedia_system_revisit_roy_fielding .
NABLAS株式会社
 
Construction Materials (Paints) in Civil Engineering
Construction Materials (Paints) in Civil EngineeringConstruction Materials (Paints) in Civil Engineering
Construction Materials (Paints) in Civil Engineering
Lavish Kashyap
 
Agents chapter of Artificial intelligence
Agents chapter of Artificial intelligenceAgents chapter of Artificial intelligence
Agents chapter of Artificial intelligence
DebdeepMukherjee9
 
Lecture - 7 Canals of the topic of the civil engineering
Lecture - 7  Canals of the topic of the civil engineeringLecture - 7  Canals of the topic of the civil engineering
Lecture - 7 Canals of the topic of the civil engineering
MJawadkhan1
 
Environment .................................
Environment .................................Environment .................................
Environment .................................
shadyozq9
 
Mode-Wise Corridor Level Travel-Time Estimation Using Machine Learning Models
Mode-Wise Corridor Level Travel-Time Estimation Using Machine Learning ModelsMode-Wise Corridor Level Travel-Time Estimation Using Machine Learning Models
Mode-Wise Corridor Level Travel-Time Estimation Using Machine Learning Models
Journal of Soft Computing in Civil Engineering
 
UNIT 3 Software Engineering (BCS601) EIOV.pdf
UNIT 3 Software Engineering (BCS601) EIOV.pdfUNIT 3 Software Engineering (BCS601) EIOV.pdf
UNIT 3 Software Engineering (BCS601) EIOV.pdf
sikarwaramit089
 
vtc2018fall_otfs_tutorial_presentation_1.pdf
vtc2018fall_otfs_tutorial_presentation_1.pdfvtc2018fall_otfs_tutorial_presentation_1.pdf
vtc2018fall_otfs_tutorial_presentation_1.pdf
RaghavaGD1
 
VISHAL KUMAR SINGH Latest Resume with updated details
VISHAL KUMAR SINGH Latest Resume with updated detailsVISHAL KUMAR SINGH Latest Resume with updated details
VISHAL KUMAR SINGH Latest Resume with updated details
Vishal Kumar Singh
 
Zeiss-Ultra-Optimeter metrology subject.pdf
Zeiss-Ultra-Optimeter metrology subject.pdfZeiss-Ultra-Optimeter metrology subject.pdf
Zeiss-Ultra-Optimeter metrology subject.pdf
Saikumar174642
 
Optimizing Reinforced Concrete Cantilever Retaining Walls Using Gases Brownia...
Optimizing Reinforced Concrete Cantilever Retaining Walls Using Gases Brownia...Optimizing Reinforced Concrete Cantilever Retaining Walls Using Gases Brownia...
Optimizing Reinforced Concrete Cantilever Retaining Walls Using Gases Brownia...
Journal of Soft Computing in Civil Engineering
 
Design Optimization of Reinforced Concrete Waffle Slab Using Genetic Algorithm
Design Optimization of Reinforced Concrete Waffle Slab Using Genetic AlgorithmDesign Optimization of Reinforced Concrete Waffle Slab Using Genetic Algorithm
Design Optimization of Reinforced Concrete Waffle Slab Using Genetic Algorithm
Journal of Soft Computing in Civil Engineering
 
Frontend Architecture Diagram/Guide For Frontend Engineers
Frontend Architecture Diagram/Guide For Frontend EngineersFrontend Architecture Diagram/Guide For Frontend Engineers
Frontend Architecture Diagram/Guide For Frontend Engineers
Michael Hertzberg
 
Understand water laser communication using Arduino laser and solar panel
Understand water laser communication using Arduino laser and solar panelUnderstand water laser communication using Arduino laser and solar panel
Understand water laser communication using Arduino laser and solar panel
NaveenBotsa
 
Introduction to Additive Manufacturing(3D printing)
Introduction to Additive Manufacturing(3D printing)Introduction to Additive Manufacturing(3D printing)
Introduction to Additive Manufacturing(3D printing)
vijimech408
 
22PCOAM16_MACHINE_LEARNING_UNIT_IV_NOTES_with_QB
22PCOAM16_MACHINE_LEARNING_UNIT_IV_NOTES_with_QB22PCOAM16_MACHINE_LEARNING_UNIT_IV_NOTES_with_QB
22PCOAM16_MACHINE_LEARNING_UNIT_IV_NOTES_with_QB
Guru Nanak Technical Institutions
 
Transport modelling at SBB, presentation at EPFL in 2025
Transport modelling at SBB, presentation at EPFL in 2025Transport modelling at SBB, presentation at EPFL in 2025
Transport modelling at SBB, presentation at EPFL in 2025
Antonin Danalet
 
Machine foundation notes for civil engineering students
Machine foundation notes for civil engineering studentsMachine foundation notes for civil engineering students
Machine foundation notes for civil engineering students
DYPCET
 
acid base ppt and their specific application in food
acid base ppt and their specific application in foodacid base ppt and their specific application in food
acid base ppt and their specific application in food
Fatehatun Noor
 
hypermedia_system_revisit_roy_fielding .
hypermedia_system_revisit_roy_fielding .hypermedia_system_revisit_roy_fielding .
hypermedia_system_revisit_roy_fielding .
NABLAS株式会社
 
Construction Materials (Paints) in Civil Engineering
Construction Materials (Paints) in Civil EngineeringConstruction Materials (Paints) in Civil Engineering
Construction Materials (Paints) in Civil Engineering
Lavish Kashyap
 
Agents chapter of Artificial intelligence
Agents chapter of Artificial intelligenceAgents chapter of Artificial intelligence
Agents chapter of Artificial intelligence
DebdeepMukherjee9
 
Lecture - 7 Canals of the topic of the civil engineering
Lecture - 7  Canals of the topic of the civil engineeringLecture - 7  Canals of the topic of the civil engineering
Lecture - 7 Canals of the topic of the civil engineering
MJawadkhan1
 
Environment .................................
Environment .................................Environment .................................
Environment .................................
shadyozq9
 
UNIT 3 Software Engineering (BCS601) EIOV.pdf
UNIT 3 Software Engineering (BCS601) EIOV.pdfUNIT 3 Software Engineering (BCS601) EIOV.pdf
UNIT 3 Software Engineering (BCS601) EIOV.pdf
sikarwaramit089
 
vtc2018fall_otfs_tutorial_presentation_1.pdf
vtc2018fall_otfs_tutorial_presentation_1.pdfvtc2018fall_otfs_tutorial_presentation_1.pdf
vtc2018fall_otfs_tutorial_presentation_1.pdf
RaghavaGD1
 
VISHAL KUMAR SINGH Latest Resume with updated details
VISHAL KUMAR SINGH Latest Resume with updated detailsVISHAL KUMAR SINGH Latest Resume with updated details
VISHAL KUMAR SINGH Latest Resume with updated details
Vishal Kumar Singh
 
Zeiss-Ultra-Optimeter metrology subject.pdf
Zeiss-Ultra-Optimeter metrology subject.pdfZeiss-Ultra-Optimeter metrology subject.pdf
Zeiss-Ultra-Optimeter metrology subject.pdf
Saikumar174642
 
Frontend Architecture Diagram/Guide For Frontend Engineers
Frontend Architecture Diagram/Guide For Frontend EngineersFrontend Architecture Diagram/Guide For Frontend Engineers
Frontend Architecture Diagram/Guide For Frontend Engineers
Michael Hertzberg
 
Understand water laser communication using Arduino laser and solar panel
Understand water laser communication using Arduino laser and solar panelUnderstand water laser communication using Arduino laser and solar panel
Understand water laser communication using Arduino laser and solar panel
NaveenBotsa
 
Introduction to Additive Manufacturing(3D printing)
Introduction to Additive Manufacturing(3D printing)Introduction to Additive Manufacturing(3D printing)
Introduction to Additive Manufacturing(3D printing)
vijimech408
 
Transport modelling at SBB, presentation at EPFL in 2025
Transport modelling at SBB, presentation at EPFL in 2025Transport modelling at SBB, presentation at EPFL in 2025
Transport modelling at SBB, presentation at EPFL in 2025
Antonin Danalet
 
Machine foundation notes for civil engineering students
Machine foundation notes for civil engineering studentsMachine foundation notes for civil engineering students
Machine foundation notes for civil engineering students
DYPCET
 
acid base ppt and their specific application in food
acid base ppt and their specific application in foodacid base ppt and their specific application in food
acid base ppt and their specific application in food
Fatehatun Noor
 

RT15 Berkeley | Multi-Terminal Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Test-Bench for Power System Stability Analyses Focused on Distributed Generation - Fraunhofer

  • 1. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -1- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil Multi-Terminal Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Test-Bench for Power System Stability Analyses Focused on Distributed Generation RT15 Berkeley, CA | 13 - 14 June, 2015 Authors: Ron Brandl, Fraunhofer IWES Dominik Geibel, Fraunhofer IWES
  • 2. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -2- Ron Brandl, Project: DEAstabil Multi-Terminal PHIL Test Bench for Power System Stability Analyses Content 1. Introduction 2. Power System Stability (PSS) 3. Simulation Environment 4. Hardware Environment 5. Power Hardware-in-the-Loop (PHIL) Simulation 6. Conclusion
  • 3. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -3- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 1. Introduction Motivation  Large increase in inverter-coupled generating units  In Germany over 50% of power generation is from PV and wind at certain times Change of future network  Loss of spinning reserves  Decentralization of power production  Future mix of power plant park will be inverter-dominated  Power system stability (PSS) has to be assured Transformation to inverter-dominated networks 0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000 80000 0:00 1:00 2:00 3:00 4:00 5:00 6:00 7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00 20:00 21:00 22:00 23:00 ProductioninMW Conventional Production > 100MW Wind Solar 18th April 2013 in Germany
  • 4. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -4- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 2. Power System Stability Conventional PSS  Focused on rotating generators  Rotor angle stability  Frequency stability  Voltage stability  Reconsideration of conventional stability assessment Source: Definition and Classification of Power System Stability, IEEE/CIGRE Joint Task Force, P. Kundur et. al. Definition of Stability
  • 5. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -5- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 2. Power System Stability Factors for network imbalance  Failure/blackout of  central power plants  large loads  transmission line  HVDC terminals  Switching operations on transmission network  Weather influence  Change of active coupling points of the interconnection to boundary networks Scenarios for different PSS disturbances
  • 6. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -6- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 2. Power System Stability
  • 7. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -7- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 3. Simulation Environment Intention of new simulation platform  Holistic simulation of transmission and distribution network for stability studies  Include dynamics of decentralized generators in the distribution network  Ability to conduct real-time simulations, esp. PHIL simulations  Evaluation of the future needs of the power system, with increasing inverter-based generation, on a scientific basis Motivation
  • 8. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -8- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 3. Simulation Environment German interconnection network  Holistic stability analyses required  >> 100.000 nodes and machines from high voltage down to low voltage level Handling  Aggregated models of distribution networks with dynamic behaviors  Development of models ≤ 110 kV which are scalable and containing the influence of distribution generators  Verification of network models based on available data of real network disturbance Dynamic Model of Distribution Networks
  • 9. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -9- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 3. Simulation Environment Benefits/Summary Advantage  Use of self-made simulation models  Access to calculation equations and simulation routine Challenges  Development of a holistic interconnection network simulation  Real-time capability and compatibility with real-time products  Parallel simulation on different cores is necessary, due to high numbers of nodes General Benefits  Flexibility  total access for developer possible  Scalability  Level of detail user defined  Expansion to new research fields
  • 10. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -10- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 4. Hardware Environment Laboratory Test bench Power Hardware-in-the-Loop test bench  Development, construction and operation of PHIL test Bench  Demonstration of the contribution of distributed generators (DER) to power system stability in a laboratory environment  Verification of the influence of power- stabilizing control method from inverter- based generators by coupling real-time simulations with larger transmission and distribution networks
  • 11. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -11- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 4. Hardware Environment Laboratory (under preparation)  Systec Laboratory, Fraunhofer IWES  Power Hardware-in-the-Loop test bench  Ametek, Power amplifier, 3x 3phase 90 kVA (single/parallel operation)  Scienlab, DC-source (battery emulator), 290 kW  TriPhase, DC-DC-AC inverter, 2x 15 kVA
  • 12. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -12- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 5. Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Simulation Benefits/Summary Intention of Power Hardware-in-the-Loop simulation  Integration of „black box“ devices for stability support (e.g. converters)  Level of detail increased due to use of the real hardware in comparison to software models  All effects of the hardware can be monitored
  • 13. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -13- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 5. Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Simulation Network Simulation Scheme German interconnection network  Transmission level  2.000 nodes  1.000 machine  Distribution level  Aggregated models  4.500 active nodes  4.000 machines  Connection point HUT  Current feedback circuit
  • 14. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -14- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 5. Power Hardware-in-the-Loop Simulation Simulation platform Controlled execution  Higher-ranked phasor simulation  Transmission network simulation  Adaption/Integration of self-made models  Classified aggregated distribution network  Distributed generator  Wind park  Photovoltaic system  CHPs  HVDC link  …
  • 15. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -15- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil 6. Conclusion Summary Summary  Reconsideration of power system stability  Focusing of inverter-dominated generators in future  Creating of holistic network simulation for stability analyses  Scenarios of conventional PSS  Research of new/upcoming PSS  Power Hardware-in-the-Loop  Laboratory Test – “Black Box” or self-programmed inverter testing Outlook  Network simulation for stability studies  Development of new control strategies for DER  Advanced test platform for DER
  • 16. © Fraunhofer IWES Slide -16- Ron Brandl Project: DEAstabil Thanks for your attention Ron Brandl Fraunhofer Intitute of Wind Energy and Energy System Technologies Koenigstor 59 34119 Kassel/Germany Ron.Brandl@iwes.fraunhofer.de Acknowledgement We acknowledge the support of our work by the German Ministry for the Environment, Nature and Nuclear Safety and the Projekträger Jülich within the project “DEA-Stabil: Beitrag der Windenergie und Photovoltaik im Verteilungsnetz zur Stabilität des deutschen Verbundnetzes” (FKZ 0325585).
  翻译: