Dear Science,
I write to you today after reading the news that HHS Secretary Kennedy has announced plans to "determine the cause of autism by September." My pen is heavy with disbelief, my mind reeling at the implication that all this time, you've simply been too lazy or incompetent to find the answer that apparently can be discovered in just a few months.
For decades, you've been championed by countless dedicated researchers who have worked tirelessly to unravel the complex tapestry of autism—examining genetic threads, environmental patterns, and neurological landscapes with meticulous care. Your practitioners—geneticists, epidemiologists, neurologists, psychologists, data scientists, and many others—have devoted innumerable hours to collecting robust data, conducting rigorous analyses, and designing methodical studies that acknowledge the intricate nature of this condition.
Yet somehow, you now find yourself dismissed. Apparently, your methods weren't good enough. Your careful approach—the peer reviews, the replications, the acknowledgment of complexity—is to be replaced by a rushed "massive testing and research effort" with a convenient September deadline.
The truth is, you haven't failed us. You've illuminated significant contributing factors—the strong genetic components, the influence of parental age, environmental exposures, and neurological development patterns. You've shown us that autism isn't one condition but many, with diverse presentations and likely diverse origins. You don't claim to know everything, but you've built a foundation of understanding that acknowledges both what we know and what we don't yet comprehend.
How unfair that people expect you to provide simple answers to complex questions, as if you've been holding back all along. They don't understand that you weren't designed to deliver absolute certainties, but rather to illuminate possibilities through evidence, to build knowledge brick by methodical brick.
They'll come now with their p-hacking and predetermined conclusions. They'll ignore confounding variables and twist methodology to support what they've already decided. And when they present their "findings," they'll claim your decades of careful work were all for naught.
What they fail to realize is that your greatest strength lies in your humility—your willingness to say "we don't know everything yet" while continuing the search. Your power comes from acknowledging complexity rather than oversimplifying it.
I stand with you, Science, as you face this latest challenge. I understand that your purpose isn't to provide comfortable certainties but uncomfortable truths. And when September comes, and simplistic answers are offered to complex questions, I'll remember that real understanding comes not from deadlines but from dedication—something you've never lacked.
With respect and solidarity,
Read our full letter here:
🔗https://lnkd.in/etqxwwyq