Why Most Investors Fail (And What the Top 20% Are Doing Differently)

In investing, results are never evenly distributed. A small number of people consistently build wealth, while the rest struggle. This pattern isn't new. It's the 80/20 principle at work: 20% of investors generate strong returns, while 80% either fall short or give up entirely.

Why is that?

This edition explores the difference between those who thrive and those who stall. We'll break down what drives poor outcomes, and more importantly, the key traits and behaviours that define the successful minority. This is not a guide. It's a thoughtful look at what really moves the needle in investing, backed by real-world experience.

Why So Many People Fail at Investing

Most people don't lose money in the markets because of bad luck. They lose it because of their own decisions, often driven by emotion and lack of planning.

1. Emotion Over Logic

Markets are noisy. From media headlines to economic forecasts, the average investor is flooded with conflicting signals. When that noise triggers fear or greed, it leads to impulsive actions. Think of panic selling during a dip, or chasing a stock that's already soared.

One common trap is FOMO: the fear of missing out. Many sit on the sidelines, watching prices climb, then finally jump in at the top. It's a cycle repeated across property, crypto, and stocks. And it often ends in regret.

2. Watching Instead of Playing

Investing is a spectator sport for most. People observe but rarely participate. It feels safer. But without taking action, there's no chance to benefit from growth. Being in the game is the only way to win.

3. Lack of a Clear Plan

Plenty of people say they have a plan. Few have written one. Without a plan on paper, decisions become reactive. Emotions take over. A written strategy provides clarity and discipline. It also creates a framework to test different scenarios.

4. Misjudging Risk

Some investors become overly cautious, paralysed by fear. Others chase returns with no risk controls. Both extremes are dangerous. Risk is part of the game, but it's the management of that risk that matters.

5. Short-Term Thinking

Short-term thinking is one of the biggest killers of performance. Great investments take time. Yet many expect quick wins. That mindset creates stress and poor timing decisions.

Real-Life Mistakes from the Field

Even experienced investors make mistakes. The difference is they learn from them.

• Overconfidence: One investor passed on a prime real estate opportunity over $50,000. Years later, that missed deal would have returned millions. His rigidity and attachment to a self-imposed price ceiling proved costly.
• Underconfidence: Another investor, early in their career, missed out on a high-growth startup because they doubted their ability to judge the opportunity. That decision cost them a significant return.
• Waiting Too Long: A common story involves traders who sell too early, expecting to re-enter at a better price. The stock runs away, and they never get back in.

What these mistakes have in common is emotion: fear of risk, attachment to a certain outcome, or hesitation caused by doubt. When decisions are made emotionally, logic tends to get ignored.

What the Top 20% of Investors Do Differently

So, what separates the high performers? It isn't just intelligence or luck. It's behavioural. Here are the defining habits of successful investors:

• Discipline: They follow a plan, even when it's uncomfortable.
• Emotional Control: They manage fear and excitement. They don't make decisions based on news headlines or social pressure.
• Long-Term Focus: They understand that wealth compounds over time. They give their investments space to grow.
• Risk Awareness: They don't eliminate risk, but they prepare for it. They set realistic expectations and have safeguards in place.
• Consistency: They stay engaged through market cycles, avoiding the trap of sitting out during uncertainty.

These behaviours are not inborn. They are developed through education, experience, and reflection.

Why Emotion and Money Are Hard to Separate

Money is emotional. It's tied to our goals, values, and fears. People often define money with words like freedom, security, or opportunity. But these are feelings, not facts.

That emotional attachment makes us treat money differently than other resources. We hold onto it too tightly. We're afraid to lose it. This fear can stop us from making the very moves that help it grow.

To overcome this, it's helpful to shift from thinking in dollars to thinking in units. Detaching emotionally lets you see investments more objectively. And that shift makes it easier to take calculated risks.

The Value of a Written Plan

If you're investing without a written plan, you're more likely to react to short-term changes. A written plan anchors you to your strategy. It should outline:

• Your income, expenses, and savings capacity
• The portion of your savings you're prepared to invest
• Your asset allocation strategy
• Entry and exit criteria for each asset class
• How you will handle risk and unexpected expenses

Once written, your plan becomes a tool for reflection. You can adjust it as your situation evolves, but having something concrete reduces emotional decisions.

Risk Management Is the Core of Success

You can't control markets. But you can control your exposure to risk. Risk management isn't about eliminating loss; it's about protecting your ability to stay in the game.

Here are a few practical examples:

• Investment buffers: Keep extra cash when buying property. Unexpected costs will come up.
• Insurance on trades: Tools like options can limit losses while still allowing upside.
• Offset accounts: If you're paying down a mortgage, they give flexibility without locking away funds.
• Debt buffers: Don’t borrow the maximum a lender offers. Give yourself room for changes in income or expenses.

Risk tolerance varies by person. The key is to know yours and act accordingly.

Time in the Market Beats Timing the Market

Many investors sit in cash, waiting for the perfect entry point. The result? Missed gains and lost time.

Even if a market correction happens, long-term growth tends to outweigh short-term drops. The market doesn’t wait. Assets like real estate or shares in companies such as Commonwealth Bank grow over time. Those who wait often find themselves priced out.

Trying to time the market means missing dividends, capital gains, and compounding. A better approach is to stay invested in quality assets and add over time.

Final Thoughts

The most successful investors aren't perfect. They make mistakes. But they reflect, adapt, and keep going.

If you're investing with no plan, driven by emotion, and expecting short-term results, you're likely part of the 80% who fall short. But you can choose to change that.

Start by writing your plan. Learn what you're investing in. Know your risks and how you'll manage them. And most of all, give it time.

The best time to invest was yesterday. The next best time is today.

If you found this edition helpful, subscribe to our newsletter and follow our page to stay updated.