Is It a Project or Just a Task? Use the Triangle Test

The concept of uniqueness is crucial in project management. As per the PMBOK® Guide (Project Management Institute, 2017), a project is "a temporary endeavor undertaken to create a unique product, service, or result." So what makes a project unique, though?

It's not just the end deliverable, but the inputs and boundaries that differentiate it from all that came before. This concept of project management uniqueness can relate closely to our approach to solving problems in coding.

Likewise, as in programming, where we choose the right data structures and algorithms based on the inputs, outputs, and limitations of a problem, in project management, the inputs (i.e. resources, people, equipment), the limitations (i.e. time, budget, place), and the expected output (i.e. product, service or outcome) all work together to make it unique. Let us continue to examine and observe how considering uniqueness in project management is similar to making decisions during programming.

The Triangle of Project Uniqueness: A Framework for Understanding Projects

When we speak of what comprises to a project being unique, we can dissect it into three fundamental points: Inputs, Outputs, and Constraints.

• Inputs: These are the resources, materials, people, technologies, tools etc. used to execute the project. For example, a project might involve different teams with varied skill sets or technologies that are being implemented for the first time.
• Outputs: The concrete goods, services, or products of the project. These may be identical between projects, but how they come into existence — out of one-of-a-kind inputs and conditions — creates each project's one-of-a-kind character.
• Constraints: These are the external factors like time, budget, location, regulatory requirements, or external risks. Constraints may differ from project to project and have a direct impact on the planning and execution of the work.

By looking at these three aspects — inputs, outputs, and constraints — we realize how each variation in one or more of them makes each project special. Even if two projects produce a very similar product as the outcome, how they're carried out will be dictated by these, leading to a distinct experience and outcome for every project.

Why Uniqueness is Important in Project Management

Its important to understand what makes a project unique since it affects how we go about planning, resource provisioning, and risk mitigation. When we identify that a task is unique, we will provision resources, set timelines, and define risks accordingly. Conversely, if we confuse a repetitive operational task with a project, we may under-resource it, not use the correct governance, or ignore critical risks.

When working on a project, consider asking yourself - What is it about this effort that's different? If the inputs, outputs, or constraints are different from what you have done in the past, then you're probably handling a different project, even if much of it will be the same. This realization ensures that the project will be handled with the right perspective and care.

Identifying Similarities with Coding: DSA

Interestingly, the idea of uniqueness in project management is similar to how we solve problems when programming. In programming, just like in project management, we decide based on the input provided, output expected, and constraints defined of the problem in question.

When solving a problem, the method we use relies on:

• Inputs: What type of data are we working with? Is it an array of numbers, a tree, a graph, or a string? The nature of input data will play a huge role in what solution we pick.
• Outputs: What are we aiming to accomplish? Are we sorting data, trying to find the shortest path, or doing an item search? Knowing what the desired output is will guide us to the proper approach.
• Constraints: Are there memory or time constraints? Do we have to consider edge cases? Constraints drive the selection of algorithm and data structure.

The uniqueness of each problem — in terms of inputs, outputs, and constraints — has a direct bearing on the solution. Any slight change in any one of these can result in an entirely different approach.

Example: Choosing Data Structures

Suppose you're constructing a search engine. The inputs could be huge amounts of text data, user queries, and preferences. The output is the list of search results presented to the user. The constraints might be fast search times, scalability, and support for large datasets.

With these in mind, the data structures you might use could differ:

• If you require fast search performance, then a hash table or BST would be most appropriate.
• To store and implement data point relationships for large-scale data, a graph can be required.
• To preserve order or deal with sequential data, linked list or queue would be the better option.

The uniqueness of the problem at hand — defined by the inputs, outputs, and limitations — determines the optimal solution. While you might be dealing with similar problems (e.g., searching for data), slight variations in the situation create drastically different decisions regarding data structures and algorithms.

Decision Flowchart: Is It a Project?

To help you make a quick assessment of whether an attempt is truly a project, you can utilize the following simple decision chart based on the Triangle of Project Uniqueness. It can be employed as a guide to establish whether the work you undertake involves distinctive components that make it a project, rather than a repetitive operational task.

Here's a simple yes or no test:

Does the work have a clearly defined deliverable?  
   ├─ Yes → Is the output tailored or non-repetitive? 
   │    ├─ Yes → ✅ It's a project  
   │    └─ No → Are the inputs (e.g. team, tools) different?
   │        ├─ Yes → ✅ It's a project  
   │        └─ No → Are the constraints (e.g. time, scope) different?   
   │              ├─ Yes → ✅ It's a project  
   │              └─ No → 🚫 Likely a repetitive or operational task
   └─ No → 🚫 Likely a repetitive or operational task        

This flowchart lets you immediately know if a task is actually a project by how different the inputs, outputs, and constraints are.

In Summary

Knowing what makes each project or coding problem special is critical to handling them well. In both areas, the unique inputs, desired results, and any restrictions or conditions define how the job must be tackled. Knowing these key factors permits improved decision-making, resource allocation, and general project management.

Considering each task in terms of its own characteristics—even if parts of it feel familiar—encourages a more careful, tailored strategy. This kind of thoughtful planning not only helps manage potential risks but also improves the chances of delivering strong, successful results.

#ProjectManagement #PMBOK #IronTriangle #DSA #IITDelhi #TriangleOfUniqueness