Negligent Referral: A Hidden Liability for Employers
HRTrainingClasses.com®
Positively Impacting HR Professionals in their Career Development Journey to Success!
In today’s workplace, references are a critical part of the hiring process, helping employers assess a candidate’s background, skills, and overall suitability for a role. However, what many HR professionals and managers fail to recognize is the legal risk associated with providing misleading or incomplete references, known as negligent referral.
When an employer knowingly gives a positive or neutral reference for an employee with a history of misconduct, especially when that employee later harms others in their new role, the referring employer can be held liable. This often-overlooked risk can lead to costly lawsuits, reputational damage, and loss of trust in an organization’s hiring practices.
One well-known case illustrating negligent referral involved a school district that failed to disclose multiple allegations of inappropriate behavior against a teacher when contacted for a reference by another district. The teacher was later hired and subsequently engaged in misconduct at the new school.
When the truth surfaced, the previous employer faced legal action for failing to warn the new employer, leading to significant financial penalties and a public scandal. This case underscores the importance of transparency in providing references, particularly when dealing with roles that involve vulnerable populations such as children, patients, or the elderly.
Negligent referral is not just about withholding negative information—it can also occur when an employer provides a glowing recommendation for an employee they know has engaged in serious misconduct. For example, in the corporate world, a financial services firm once gave a positive reference for an executive who had previously been terminated for fraudulent activities.
The new employer, relying on this misleading reference, hired the individual, who later engaged in similar unethical behavior, causing substantial financial losses. When the case went to court, the referring employer was held accountable for failing to disclose critical information. This case serves as a stark reminder that honesty in references is not just ethical—it is legally necessary.
Many employers, however, hesitate to provide detailed references due to concerns about defamation lawsuits. This fear often leads organizations to adopt neutral reference policies, only confirming dates of employment and job titles. While this approach minimizes risk, it also creates a loophole where past misconduct goes unreported, potentially putting future employers and their employees at risk. Employers do have legal protection under the qualified privilege doctrine, which shields them from defamation claims as long as their references are given in good faith, without malice, and based on factual information.
But the best protection is not silence, it is truth and documentation. Employers who provide truthful references and maintain records that support their statements significantly reduce their legal risk. If a former employee challenges a reference, having clear documentation of their performance, disciplinary actions, or termination reasons proves that what was said or written was the truth, a defense no lawsuit can override.
To navigate this complex issue, companies must establish clear reference-checking policies that balance legal compliance with professional integrity. This includes documenting employee performance issues, ensuring HR handles reference requests, and using carefully crafted reference policies that allow for honest and factual responses.
Employers should also seek legal counsel when unsure about what information can or should be disclosed. Additionally, maintaining transparency in internal records ensures that, should a reference request arise, the employer can provide accurate, factual information without exposing the organization to liability.
Recommended by LinkedIn
Negligent referral is a legal landmine that too many employers overlook, until it’s too late. In an era where lawsuits are increasingly common, HR professionals and hiring managers must recognize that giving references is not just a courtesy; it is a responsibility. While qualified privilege provides legal protection, the most effective safeguard is telling the truth and being able to prove it.
A careless or dishonest reference can have devastating consequences, not only for the new employer but also for potential victims of an unfit hire. By embracing honesty, documentation, and due diligence, companies can protect themselves from liability while fostering an ethical hiring culture that prioritizes safety, transparency, and responsible hiring practices.
Elga Lejarza
Founder & CEO