The Benefits of Delusional Thinking at Work
Delusional thinking is usually framed as a red flag—something to be corrected, or coached out of existence. But in workplace psychology, not all delusions are created equal. When channeled constructively, mild forms of delusional thinking—what psychologists sometimes call positive illusions—can lead to improved confidence, innovation, and even performance. For HR professionals and team leaders, this isn’t a call to tolerate fantasy but an invitation to recognize the strategic use of selective optimism.
What Is “Delusional Thinking” at Work?
In management psychology, delusional thinking can exist on a spectrum. On one end lies detachment from reality. On the other end—where most high-performers, visionaries, and startup founders live—is unrealistic optimism, inflated self-efficacy, and goal overcommitment. These cognitive distortions, when mild, form the basis of what psychologists Shelley Taylor and Jonathon Brown call positive illusions—self-deceptions that can have adaptive value.
The Upside of Positive Illusions
Elevated Self-Efficacy Beliefs. Employees who overestimate their capabilities tend to set more ambitious goals and pursue them with greater persistence. Even if outcomes fall short, the stretch often leads to growth. In performance review cycles, this is visible as increased goal attainment scores, especially when stretch goals are tied to OKRs.
Resilience in Uncertainty. When employees hold a slightly delusional belief that “we’ll find a way,” they’re more likely to persevere during organizational change or external volatility. In psychological terms, this is adaptive confidence. It shows up in metrics like lower attrition during change periods and higher employee engagement scores in pulse surveys.
Increased Risk Tolerance for Innovation. Innovators often have to believe in ideas that aren’t immediately feasible. That belief is a socially acceptable form of delusion. By allowing psychological safety for “what if?” and “why not me?”, HR fosters what Teresa Amabile called the inner work life effect—a cognitive-emotional loop where belief precedes performance. The results? Higher creative output, more patents, and greater cross-functional experimentation.
Delusional Thinking vs. Toxic Overconfidence
Not all confidence is created equal. While constructive delusion—the belief in one’s ability to rise above obstacles or outperform expectations—can fuel progress, toxic overconfidence is its dysfunctional cousin. It looks similar on the surface but corrodes team dynamics, inflates risk, and undermines performance over time. Understanding the difference is essential for HR professionals and team leaders who want to protect both psychological safety and performance integrity.
Watch for Dunning-Kruger Spikes
The Dunning-Kruger effect describes a cognitive bias where individuals with low ability in a domain overestimate their competence. In the workplace, this often shows up in:
What to do: Build in feedback loops early and often. 360-degree reviews, peer check-ins, and skill-based milestones can gently recalibrate overconfidence into growth-oriented ambition.
Recommended by LinkedIn
Avoidance of Accountability Metrics
Toxic overconfidence often sidesteps measurement. Employees stuck in this mindset may:
What to do: HR and managers should link confidence with clarity. Set shared expectations with measurable outcomes, but also make space for post-mortems and debriefs. When metrics are framed as learning tools instead of judgments, they reintroduce reality into the feedback cycle.
Dismissal of Constructive Feedback
Employees caught in delusional overdrive may reject input as personal criticism or unnecessary micromanagement. This defensiveness can slow team progress, stall individual development, and undermine trust.
What to do: Foster a growth mindset culture where feedback is normalized and even celebrated. Train managers in team management psychology, and model feedback as a shared act of improvement—not a correction of flaws.
From Illusion to Impact: HR's Role
Incorporate "Aspirational Metrics". Add a “Moonshot Index” to your performance rubric—tracking not just completion, but pursuit of bold, high-risk, high-reward goals. This encourages constructive delusion in a structured way.
Celebrate Near Misses. Reward courageous attempts even if results fall short. Performance cultures overly focused on outcomes can stifle the very delusional optimism that drives breakthrough success.
Train Managers in Cognitive Reframing. Use management psychology techniques to help team leaders support ambitious thinking without encouraging recklessness. Methods like future pacing and growth-oriented reflection help build psychological safety around big thinking.
Reality Has Its Place—But So Does the Dream!
Workplaces thrive when grounded thinking meets aspirational belief. In fact, many high-performing teams run on a shared, slightly inflated belief in what’s possible. For HR and team leaders, the goal isn’t to eliminate delusional thinking—it’s to shape it, support it, and integrate it into the performance ecosystem.
Curious how Management Psychology can elevate your team’s performance? Contact our leading Corporate Therapist, Dr. Vilija Biciunaite , for tailored trainings and team sessions that drive real results. Let’s talk about what your people need—before they even know they need it.