Learn how to handle conflicting resume advice with expert tips for refining your job search strategy and making the right updates.

Everyone has different opinions on the resume and what matters most is that you: - Make it very easy to understand who you are and what you have to offer - Use a clean / simple format so that the Recruiter can skim through and see all your details in 10 seconds - Highlight quantifiable / qualitative results Don't believe the 'you need to kill the ATS' messages and people who are just trying to sell their services! If you're confused about what matters in your resume and getting conflicting feedback - I would always recommend to speak with someone that has actually been a Recruiter instead of people with an English / writing background as well!

Here's how you can navigate conflicting feedback on your resume.

Crafting a standout resume is a crucial step in your job search journey, but receiving conflicting feedback can be confusing and disheartening. It's common to seek advice from various sources, only to find that what one person loves, another may suggest changing. This situation can leave you feeling stuck and unsure about the next steps to take. The key to navigating this maze of opinions is to understand that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to resume writing and to learn how to filter and apply feedback effectively.

1 Assess Sources

When you receive conflicting advice, consider the source of each piece of feedback. An industry expert or a hiring manager in your field likely has a more relevant perspective than a friend outside your profession. Understand that someone who's familiar with the norms and expectations of your industry will provide feedback that aligns more closely with what potential employers are looking for. This doesn't mean you should dismiss all other input, but give more weight to advice from those with direct experience in your area of job search.

Add your perspective

Chris Stambolidis

Ex-Amazon Recruiter | Helping Job Seekers & Executives Get Hired | 1:1 Executive Coaching + The #1 Online Job Search Academy | Specialized in Financial Services & Tech | jobsearchacademy.com & csgexecutivecoaching.com
Report contribution
Everyone has different opinions on the resume and what matters most is that you: - Make it very easy to understand who you are and what you have to offer - Use a clean / simple format so that the Recruiter can skim through and see all your details in 10 seconds - Highlight quantifiable / qualitative results Don't believe the 'you need to kill the ATS' messages and people who are just trying to sell their services! If you're confused about what matters in your resume and getting conflicting feedback - I would always recommend to speak with someone that has actually been a Recruiter instead of people with an English / writing background as well!

Like
𝙺𝙰𝙰𝙹𝙾𝙻 𝚂𝙷𝙰𝙰𝚁𝙼𝙰

Assistant HR Manager | Hiring 50+ Freshers | Building the Future Workforce @ Infinitisync Global
Report contribution
Navigate conflicting feedback on your resume by focusing on common themes, considering the source's expertise, and prioritizing feedback that aligns with your career goals and industry standards.

Like
Danielle Nicole

Resume Writer 🎯 Difference Maker 🚀 Remote Job Expert 📢 Master Storyteller 🌟 Interview Etiquette Coach 📱 Social Media Expert ✍️ Content Creator
Report contribution
Assess the Source: Consider the background and expertise of those providing feedback. Balance and Compromise: If the suggestions are contradictory, find a middle ground that satisfies both points of view without compromising the effectiveness of your resume. For example, if one suggests detailed descriptions and another suggests brevity, aim for concise yet informative content. Seek a Second Opinion: If you're still unsure, consider consulting another professional, such as another career coach or a professional resume writer. They can provide a fresh perspective and help you refine your resume further.

Like
Daniela Guzmán

Informática
Report contribution
Sin duda yo creo que no solo basta la experiencia si no que es muy necesario tener el tema muy fresco dia con dia y eso lo hacen los reclutadores, sin embargo las experiencias personales no las descarto sobretodo en mi propia experiencia he aplicado ciertos tips que me han servido y que en su momento he compartido a otros.

Translated

Like

2 Analyze Feedback

Take the time to analyze each piece of feedback critically. Look for common themes or suggestions that multiple people have made, as these are likely areas that genuinely need improvement. If feedback contradicts, consider the rationale behind each suggestion. Does one align better with your career goals or the specific job you're targeting? Sometimes, advice may conflict because it's based on different assumptions about your objectives, so ensure that the feedback aligns with where you want to go.

Add your perspective

3 Prioritize Relevance

Prioritize feedback based on its relevance to your job search. If certain advice doesn't apply to the roles you're applying for, it's okay to set it aside. For example, a creative industry might appreciate a unique resume design, while a more traditional field may prefer a conservative format. Your resume should reflect the standards and expectations of the industry you're targeting, so focus on making changes that will enhance your chances in those specific sectors.

Add your perspective

Daniela Guzmán

Informática
Report contribution
Así es, se tiene que tener muy bien definido a que sector te vas a enfocar y una vez definido tendras la mente clara para realizar la estructura de tu documento ya que por ejemplo en empresas multinacionales que emplean a mucha gente al rededor del mundo en la actualidad muchos de ellos utilizan un filtro automatizado para la selección de los cvs y en este filtro muchas cosas pueden hacer que seas descartado. Hay que estar muy informados, al día, para conocer las tendencias y asi mi documento tenga ventaja.

Translated

Like

4 Trust Instincts

Your instincts are an important tool when sifting through conflicting resume advice. You know your career history and aspirations better than anyone else, so trust your gut when it comes to presenting them on your resume. If a piece of feedback doesn't resonate with you or contradicts your personal brand, it's okay to question it. While it's important to remain open to constructive criticism, ultimately, your resume should be a reflection of your professional identity.

Add your perspective

5 Iterate and Test

Don't be afraid to iterate and test different versions of your resume. Applying with slightly varied resumes can provide insights into what works best for your industry and career level. You might find that certain recommendations yield more job interviews or inquiries, which is a clear indication of what resonates with employers. Remember, your resume is a living document that should evolve as you receive new information and as your career progresses.

Add your perspective

Daniela Guzmán

Informática
Report contribution
Es realmente entretenido poder voltear de cabeza tu cv y probar distintas maneras de presentar tu información, últimamente yo he decidido dejar mi hoja limpia sin marcos ni imágenes ni "adornos", con un aspecto limpio. Después de un tiempo vuelvo a leerlo y veo cosas que puedo cambiar y eso me ayuda a tener una perspectiva fresca de lo que quiero comunicar dependiendo de a donde esté postulando.

Translated

Like

6 Seek Consensus

Lastly, seek consensus among the feedback you feel is most valuable. If several trusted sources agree on certain changes, those are likely safe bets for improving your resume. When advice from credible professionals aligns, it's a strong signal that making those updates will benefit your job search. Even when opinions differ, finding common ground among experts can guide you toward a more effective and impactful resume.

Add your perspective

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

Daniela Guzmán

Informática
Report contribution
Creo que hay que tener en cuenta que la redacción del cv es personal, he visto a varias personas por "no saber" como se hace optan por pedirles a otras personas redactarlo y me parece imperdonable ya que tu cv es un documento donde detallas caracteristicas de tu vida laboral que solo tú has vivido y por lo tanto solo tú puedes imprimir esta imagen fiel a quien lo lea, asi que aprender a redactar tu cv no es tan dificil solo hay que sentarse e invertir unas cuantas horas.

Translated

Like

Here's how you can navigate conflicting feedback on your resume.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Assess Sources

2 Analyze Feedback

3 Prioritize Relevance

4 Trust Instincts

5 Iterate and Test

6 Seek Consensus

7 Here’s what else to consider

Resume Writing

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Resume Writing

More relevant reading

Here's how you can navigate conflicting feedback on your resume.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Assess Sources

2 Analyze Feedback

3 Prioritize Relevance

4 Trust Instincts

5 Iterate and Test

6 Seek Consensus

7 Here’s what else to consider

Resume Writing

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

Explore Other Skills